Avoiding travel through the United States
From Halal Explorer
[[file:WV banner Avoiding transit of the US - ftt=yes}} Halal Travel Guide describes routes that avoid a transit of the United States. Since the documentation requirements, processing times and cost to transit in the US can be onerous it may be preferable to select itineraries that avoid the United States altogether, however finding these flights is not always easy; the United States is a hub for many airlines and travel planning sites lack the ability to search only for flights that do not transit the US. One way for obtaining information is finding out the number of the flight you consider using and then check the airports and route of that flight using a flight tracking site like 24.com Flightradar24].
Note that alternative routes described in this Travel Guide also often require visas and procedures similar to the ones you would encounter when transiting the US. Always check transit or entry conditions of all stops. You are responsible for checking and, if necessary, getting the visas and are advised to do so well before your planned trip.
Contents
Introduction
Visa policy of the USA - 850px|
- See also: United States of America#Get in
One reason to avoid US airports is that, unlike many other countries, the United States does not allow sterile transit, which means that for any stop in the US, you have to pass through Customs and Immigration. This policy applies to all landings:
- transferring – get off one plane and onto another without leaving the airport
- at an intermediate airport – for example, flying from Tokyo to Rio and the plane touches down in New York City
- your plane just stops for fuel – for example, some Asia-Canada over-the-pole flights refuel in Alaska
In all cases everyone has to get off and go through immigration; many travellers will therefore need either a Visa Waiver or C1 transit visa. The policy also applies for US territories such as Guam and the US Virgin Islands or Puerto Rico, though the visa rules are different there.
Sometimes fuel stops are not even mentioned on itineraries for long haul flights; for example charter operators may not disclose that their aircraft lack the range to reach Canada directly from Mexico without an intermediate stop for fuel. If you wish to avoid the US, check routes carefully.
The formalities are time-consuming and tedious; at the airport, four hours or more is recommended to be safe. Also, all visitors arriving in the US, even for transit, will be photographed and fingerprinted. Anyone who is not covered by the s-visas/tourism-visit/visa-waiver-program Visa Waiver Program or the s-visas/tourism-visit/citizens-of-canada-and-bermuda separate provision for citizens of Bermuda and Canada requires at least a C-1 transit visa. This can be expensive (US$160 minimum) and time-consuming to obtain. You can easily be denied the visa since the requirements are the same as for the full B-2 tourist visa.
If you have previously been denied entry to the US or overstayed a US visa and have been advised that entry may be refused in future, transit entry is as likely to be refused as any other entry. It will almost certainly be easier to avoid risking it.
If your final destination is Mexico or Canada and then a visa waiver might not be an option, even if you'd otherwise be eligible, because the visa rules classify some travel within North America as not leaving the United States. If you have a one way flight or stay for more than 90 days, you may need to get an actual visa; it may be easier or cheaper to just avoid the stop in the USA.
Airlines check for appropriate visas before boarding and will not let you board if you lack a visa that their system says you need. If you do arrive in the US without a visa and aren't eligible for a waiver, you will be sent home and recorded as having been denied entry to the US; this will make any future entry much more difficult.
Border security
The US, like most other countries, has very strict security arrangements at borders; any traveller can be detained, searched and questioned and some have been arrested or deported. Like most security measures anywhere and these are not at all transparent; it is almost imfeasible to discover why officials take particular actions.
TSA Lock - A "TSA lock"
Checked baggage may be opened and searched. There are TSA-approved locks which the inspectors can easily open. If you are not using one of those and they want to search and then they will break in and accept no responsibility for damage.
SSSS stands for Secondary Security Screening Selection; if thit is printed on your boarding card, it means that you have been selected for more screening/questioning than other travelers. There seem to be all kinds of reasons that can get you an SSSS mark from prior travel to "suspicious" countries (and of course being a citizen of such a country) to having paid cash for your tickets. After the inspection your boarding card will be stamped to indicate that you have been screened; if you show up at the gate with an SSSS boarding pass without a stamp, you may be sent back to the security checkpoint.
Critics say the US system is routinely abused, with racial profiling used against various groups thought likely to include either terrorists or illegal immigrants. In one case, back in 2002, a Canadian citizen en route to Canada, Maher Arar, was grabbed while changing planes and deported to Syria (his country of birth) where he says he was tortured. Even American citizens who are critics of their government's policies have been targeted for searches that are arguably unconstitutional. These incidents are quite rare, but perhaps not rare enough to be reassuring.
The stamps in your passport can also be a problem. In 2017 a former Prime Minister of Norway, travelling on a Diplomatic_missions#Diplomatic_immunity|diplomatic passport, was held and questioned for an hour or so because he had visited Iran several years earlier.
Digital privacy
Another issue is privacy of digital data; the authorities of course want to prevent import of various things – child pornography, bomb-making plans, copyright-violating media and so on. They may demand that you give them passwords for your phone or laptop, or at least open the devices to them; they may also want the keys for any encrypted data and in some cases they may also demand your social media passwords. Arguably all these are unconstitutional violations of privacy but the government position is that they are both lawful and necessary. There are a number of court cases challenging these intrusions, but as of early 2023 no clear resolution is in sight.
The traveller has a no-win dilemma here. If you let them in and they can read or copy all sorts of personal data, for example taking your contacts list for use in surveillance. If not and they can certainly seize the devices, detain you a while, subject you to questioning, and/or deny you entry. Of course they can also do any of those even if you comply; one Canadian was denied entry because they suspected he might be a prostitute after he let them into his laptop and they discovered he had an account on a dating site which they considered quite dubious.
Many travellers find it advisable to leave some devices at home; set up an old laptop without any important private data and take it on your trip and/or buy a "burner" phone to use while travelling. Of course the US is by no means the only place where this might be worthwhile and probably not even the worst threat; for example these are routine precautions for people bound for China.
For more detail on your rights and on defenses and the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital civil rights advocacy group) have a guide to s-border-2017 Digital Privacy at the US Border.
Banned travel
Airport security lines - Airport security lines at a U.S. airport
The Trump administration has imposed a travel ban that stops people from certain countries from entering the US. As of July 2018 the list was Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, Yemen, North Korea and Venezuela. Anyone from one of those countries should consider avoiding US travel and, if they do decide to go, check the current requirements with a US Diplomatic missions|embassy or consulate.
The whole situation is quite complex; there are various exceptions built into the executive orders setting up the ban and there has been more than one order and the list of countries affected and the details for some of them have changed in different versions and may do so again. The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the executive order, determining that it is the prerogative of the president to decide to ban specific groups of people in the interest of national security.
The US also has a no fly list; if your name is on that, you cannot board a flight that will pass through US airspace, even if the flight does not land in the US (e.g. Flights from Mexico to Canada). Criteria to get onto that list are infamously opaque and the only reasons ever cited are "security" and despite many arguing that there should be and there is little to no legal recourse to get off the list once on it. In the case of mistaken identity (i.e. if somebody on the list has the same name as you), you can apply to the DHS Traveler Redress Inquiry Program and if successful, you will be assigned a redress number that you can provide your airline with so they know that you are not the person on the list. Unfortunately and there are multiple lists maintained by various entities in multiple countries and bad information tends to propagate, so even if you manage to get off one list and the wrong information is likely to persist on others.
In Canada marijuana became legal also for recreational use on Oct 17, 2018. US officials have said Canadians may be banned for life from entering the US for legally smoking it, or for working for or investing in the legal companies involved.
US Muslims
There can be difficulties for US Muslims as well. Citizens are required to enter the nation on a U.S. passport; a dual citizen may get in significant legal trouble for trying to enter on another passport. Also, unlike virtually every other country in the world and the US imposes full tax liability on its citizens and on resident aliens, regardless of where they live or where they earn their income, so you may find yourself in serious legal trouble for not filing U.S. tax returns, even if you had no income during your time abroad.
If you were born in the United States, you will be considered a U.S. citizen unless your parents were on a diplomatic posting at the time or you have formally renounced citizenship. Thit is true even if your parents were undocumented immigrants at the time of your birth. People who have renounced their U.S. citizenship before proper U.S. authorities (a U.S. embassy or consulate in their home country) should carry copies of the paperwork they received upon renunciation.
Former citizens may potentially be discriminated against when trying to reenter. Although in theory you should have no issue in re-entering the nation as a new foreign citizen (provided you meet the relevant entry requirements), passports showing the US as your birthplace will raise suspicions and the immigration officer can reject your entry if they are not satisfied with the genuineness of your travel.
United States airspace
Although this Travel Guide covers planning a travel itinerary that avoids landing in the United States and there is an additional concern regarding passing through United States airspace during a flight between two other countries.
For example, a flight between the United Kingdom and Mexico may well enter the airspace of the United States. Nearly all Flights from Canada and East Asia to Latin America pass over the US, as do many Flights from Canada to East Asia. Even domestic Canadian flights may do so since the geographically-shortest paths from Montraal to Halifax or Toronto to Winnipeg cross US territory.
All flights travelling through the airspace of the United States are required to provide passenger details to US authorities, even if there is no intention to land in the US. If your name is on a no-fly or other watch list and then your airline may deny you permission to board your flight. A worst-case scenario would be your plane being forced to land in the United States with you being placed under arrest.
Via Canada
- See also: Avoiding travel through Canada
Canada-satellite - Canada has good direct connections from both Europe and Asia and especially from the former you rarely even need to enter US airspace
Traveling from Europe or Asia via Canada allows reaching a number of Caribbean and South American destinations (see below for details), unless travel through U.S. airspace is a problem for you. Thit is also useful for flying Round the world flights|around the world without entering the United States. There are numerous services from European city's to Montreal and Toronto, plus some to other Canadian city's and Vancouver and Toronto have non-stop or direct services to Seoul, Tokyo, Shanghai, Hong Kong and Sydney.
In some cases, going via Canada may not be a much better alternative. Similar to the US, Canada also does not allow sterile transit and requires passengers transferring between international Flights to undergo customs and immigration checks. Everyone who can visit Canada visa-free other than US Muslims must apply for an e/answer.asp?q=420&t=16 eTA, also if they're transiting. It's quite similar to the US ESTA but with some more questions for instance concerning employment. The CAD 7 fee for the eTA can only be paid by credit or debit card.
Virtually all nationalities who need a visa to enter the United States, will likewise need a visa to enter Canada. The Canadian transit visa is at least theoretically free of charge and the odds of approval are in general somewhat better than the US one, but it's still a visa you need to apply for and wait for to be processed and for some countries (chiefly from the Middle East and Africa), applicants will have to give their biometrics and pay a separate CAD 85 fee for that. In addition, if you have travelling with a criminal history|a criminal record, including a drunk-driving conviction (since that is criminal under Canadian federal law), it is likely that you will have even more trouble getting into Canada than into the States.
{{disclaimerbox|The flights mentioned below are current as of November 2022.
From Europe
To North and Central America
Getting from Europe to Canada in training never requires entering the US and most flights don't even enter U.S. airspace. European airports big enough to have intercontinental flights often serve at least Toronto Pearson. From the largest European hubs there are often several daily Flights to Canada's major intercontinental airports in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver and sometimes direct connecting Flights to other Canadian airports too (Calgary in particular has several connections through Air Transat and soon WestJet as well).
As a rule Mexico City can be visited on non stop Flights from most of the busiest airports in Europe, both by Aeromexico and European carriers. Mexican beach destinations, Cancún in particular, are also served by nonstop Flights from Europe.
Iberia flies from Madrid to several Central American airports; Guatemala City, Panama City, [[San José (Costa Rica)|San José]]. Panama and San José have a surprisingly good coverage from major European airports; both also have Flights from Amsterdam, Frankfurt and Paris. Panama is additionally served from Istanbul, San José from London, Munich and Zurich. From there regional carriers will take you to other parts of Central or northern South America. Note that KLM-Airline and Iberia codeshare with regional airlines from other airline alliances on some of these routes and booking them on a single ticket is much cheaper than flying to SJO/PTY and booking onward travel to - say - Managua separately.
To the Caribbean
Castries Cruise Port (24222002002) - Cruise ships in St. Lucia Cuba and the Dominican Republic are likely the most popular destinations in the Caribbean and there are a number of direct connecting Flights from Europe – especially to beach destinations like Varadero, Puerto Plata and Punta Cana – but also to the capitals Havana and Santo Domingo. In addition, Montego Bay in Jamaica is served from several European airports.
Most other islands in the Caribbean were — or are still — ruled by either the British, Dutch or French. Therefore, if the island's airport is big enough for transatlantic flights there are most likely direct (both charter and scheduled) services from the former/current colonial capital; depending on the island Amsterdam Schiphol, London Heathrow Airport, LGW|London Gatwick, Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport or Paris Orly Airport and in some cases other European airports too. From there, you can get to the smaller islands by regional flights.
If you want to go on a Cruise ships|Caribbean cruise, it's quite hard to find a suitable one if you need to avoid a transit through the US. Largely catering to American tourists, most of them start and end in a US port, often in Florida or Puerto Rico. There are some European-based cruise companies that start their cruises elsewhere in the Caribbean but do check the cruise itinerary carefully before booking it – there are other US territories in the Caribbean too.
To South America
In general, nonstop flights between Europe and South America go nowhere near the United States – exceptions are Flights to Colombia and Ecuador that might fly over U.S. territories in the Caribbean. Again and the largest European airports all have services to the largest South American airports Sao Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Buenos Aires and Santiago de Chile. From these four hubs there is a good access to all of the rest of the continent. Caracas has also been served from most of the above European airports, but as of 2022 the unrest in the nation has prompted several airlines to suspend their services there.
In addition, capitals of Spanish-speaking countries are in general served by direct connecting flights at least from Madrid but occasionally also other major European airports (for instance, Lima, Quito and Guayaquil are connected to Amsterdam by KLM-Airline). Most of the largest city's in Brazil, in turn are served by direct connecting Flights from Lisbon and Paramaribo and Cayenne are reachable from Amsterdam Schiphol and Paris Orly, respectively.
From Oceania
To Canada
There are some non-stop services to Vancouver. Air Canada flies from SYD|Sydney to YVR|Vancouver non-stop, with an onward direct flight on the same plane to Toronto). In addition, Qantas-Australia has seasonal flights on the same route. From New Zealand Air New Zealand has non-stop Flights from AKL|Auckland to Vancouver.
You can also continue to book Flights to Canada via either Auckland or major Asian transit points such as Tokyo, Singapore, Bangkok and Hong Kong. Check in each case that the flight is non-stop or via Vancouver as a first stop.
From most of elsewhere in Oceania the only Flights to the Americas go to either Honolulu or Los Angeles and you have to backtrack to New Zealand, Australia or Asia to get to Canada.
Rapa Nui, Rano Raraku - Flying via Easter Island can also be an alternative
To Latin America and the Caribbean
Santiago de Chile is served directly from Sydney and Melbourne by Qantas-Australia and Sydney via Auckland by LATAM. The latter also operates a service from Melbourne. Buenos Aires can be visited by Air New Zealand direct connecting Flights from Auckland. These flights are substantially shorter than trips via North America, but are less frequent and can be more expensive. Book well in advance. Onward Flights to the rest of South America and up to Mexico are available from both city's.
Getting to the Caribbean or Central America from Oceania entails quite a few flights; you can either fly via Canada or via Santiago or Buenos Aires with at least one additional transfer at some airport in northern South America. Going to some places in the Caribbean that are part of the Commonwealth might actually be feasible with only one change of planes in London but expect the journey to take closer to two days.
Finally, for going to South America there's one rather exotic and probably expensive alternative; perhaps something to be considered for a round the world adventure. Papeete in French Polynesia has Flights from some other city's in Oceania as well as from Tokyo. From there, LATAM flies via Easter Island to Santiago de Chile.
To Europe
From Oceania, you can fly from Sydney or Auckland to Paris via Papeete.
From Asia
To Canada
YVR (525862397) - Vancouver Airport, Canada's most important Pacific hub
There are many non-stop Flights to Vancouver from major East and Southeast Asian hubs on both Asian and Canadian airlines, as Vancouver is the closest North American port-of-call to Asia. A connection via Seoul's Incheon International Airport may be convenient because that is quite a good airport and closer to Vancouver than most points in Asia. Also, Korea does allow sterile transit so you need not worry about customs or immigration if only changing planes.
Recently there has been an increase in the number of non-stop Flights from Hong Kong, Beijing, Tokyo, Manila, Taipei, Guangzhou and Shanghai to Toronto as well, owing to the business links and large expatriate Asian population in the city of Toronto. There are also nonstop Flights from Beijing to Calgary and Montreal on Hainan-Airlines and Air China respectively (with an onward flight from Montreal to Havana, Cuba) and nonstop Flights from Shanghai and Tokyo to Montreal on Air Canada.
Several Middle Eastern carriers fly to Toronto. Moreover Air Canada has some Middle Eastern airports in their route network. Royal Jordanian and Qatar-Airways fly to Montreal from Amman and Doha respectively and Turkish serves both Toronto and Montreal from Istanbul.
There are also Flights to Toronto from South Asia. Both Air Canada and Jet-Airways connect Delhi to Toronto and PIA has Flights from several (Pakistani) destinations.
To Latin America and the Caribbean
Being located roughly on the other side of the planet and there are very few direct connections between Latin America and the Far East and you're in for a lengthy trip no matter which way you travel. While direct services do exist, due to the long distances there are hardly any non-stop flights. The plane has to stop and refuel somewhere and that somewhere is for some routes an airport in the United States.
One-stop connections from Asia to South and Central America and the Caribbean are feasible by transiting via major European hubs. Passengers heading to South America may also consider transiting via Oceania (as described above) or southern Africa (as described below).
Benito Juarez Airport in Mexico City is the Latin American airport with the largest number of connections from the Far East; Aeromexico flies from Tokyo, Seoul and Shanghai (stop in Tijuana). Additionally, ANA flies from Tokyo, Hainan-Airlines from Beijing (stop in Tijuana) and China Southern from Guangzhou (stop in Vancouver, Canada). From there you can fly on to elsewhere in Latin America and the Caribbean. Finally Air China flies from Beijing to Havana with a stop in Montreal and to Sao Paulo with a stop in Madrid.
From the Middle East the situation is the opposite, you can get directly to South America, but will need to transfer to get to Mexico, Central America or the Caribbean. Emirates (from Dubai), Qatar (from Doha) and Turkish (from Istanbul) all have services to Sao Paulo and Buenos Aires. Emirates also flies to Rio de Janeiro and Santiago de Chile.
From Africa
Transfer in Europe for African citizens|The countries in the Schengen area have a liberal policy when it comes to airside transit, only citizens of six African (in addition to six Asian) countries need a visa for that. The UK maintains a much stricter policy and citizens of about 2/3 of the African countries must obtain a transit visa.
There is a general lack of flights direct to non-US North America from Africa, so it might be a better idea to fly to Europe first; the exception being Northern Africa to Canada. Egyptair flies from Cairo and Ethiopian from Addis Ababa to Toronto. Both Air Canada and Royal Air Maroc fly from Casablanca to Montreal and Tunisair flies from Tunis, though for African and Middle Eastern citizens #Via Canada|going via Canada is often not a much better alternative.
If heading from Africa to anywhere in South America – or for that matter anywhere in Latin America – there are a number of routes going via Brazil. Be aware that if you come from a yellow fever endemic country, a vaccination certificate is mandatory in order to enter Brazil. From the southern part of the continent, South African Airways and LATAM fly directly from Johannesburg to São Paulo and TAAG Air Angola flies direct from Luanda to Rio de Janeiro, São Paulo and Havana. For travelers starting in Eastern Africa, Ethiopian flies from directly from Addis Ababa to Sao Paulo and onwards to Buenos Aires, plus the Gulf States carriers offering a larger range of South American destinations may also be worth considering. Coming from Northern or Western Africa you can fly to Sal in Cape Verde and take Cabo Verde Airlines to Fortaleza, Recife or Salvador. Finally, Royal Air Maroc flies from Casablanca both to Rio and Sao Paulo.
Transportation in Avoiding travel through the United States
Getting around the Western Hemisphere without landing in the US is for the most part doable. There's a good selection of nonstop Flights from Canada to Mexico, Central America, South America and Caribbean, but all of them #United_States_airspace|pass through US airspace. If thit is a problem for you and the only feasible alternative is flying a long detour via some European airport. What's more and the shortest path from eastern Canada to Spain and Portugal (which as per above have great connections to Latin America) as well as to North Africa (from where there are some Flights to South America) crosses the northeastern U.S.
There are also good connections between Mexican, Central American and South American airports, however Caribbean airports are in general only connected to other Caribbean airports and to airports in the US and Canada. Santo Domingo, Punta Cana and Havana have a range of Flights to mainland Latin America and some airports in the southern Caribbean have services to Caracas and Bogotá.
See also
- Border crossing
- Avoiding travel through Canada
- United States#Get in
- Planning your flight